Good Guys Garage

Good Guys Garage ico

(162 reviews)

Auto Repair StationsOhioLicking CountyNewarkSouth 4th Street

Licking County . Ohio

Close Now

  • Overview
  • Intro
  • Photos
  • Location
  • Reviews
  • +1 740-349-4897
  • www.goodguysgarageohio.com
  • 23 S 4th St, Newark, OH 43055, USA

Operating Hours

Monday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday 7:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

Good Guys Garage Introduce

Welcome to Good Guys Garage, your go-to auto repair shop and parts store located at 23 S 4th St, Newark, OH 43055. Open from Monday to Friday, we cater to all your vehicle maintenance needs with a focus on quality service and reliability. Whether you're looking for new tires or engine repairs, our team is here to help.

At Good Guys Garage, we pride ourselves on offering comprehensive auto repair services alongside an extensive inventory of car parts. Our shop is ideal for both individual customers seeking quick fixes and fleet operators needing bulk supplies. We aim to provide a seamless experience, ensuring your vehicle gets the attention it deserves.

Our characteristics set us apart: we stock a vast range of auto parts, from common components to hard-to-find specialties, all at competitive prices. Our commitment to excellence extends beyond repairs; we offer expert advice and services tailored to your specific needs. For instance, our tire shop ensures precise installations, though we acknowledge that isolated incidents can occur, as highlighted in some reviews.

Enjoy promotional deals like discounts for military personnel or first-time customers. While specific offers vary, we consistently strive to provide value through reliable service and quality products.

Customer Feedback

Our customer feedback reflects a mix of experiences. Many appreciate our efficient service and knowledgeable staff. However, some reviews note issues with workmanship and professionalism:

  • A customer shared a negative experience regarding rim damage during tire installation and the lack of resolution.
  • Another recounted poor handling of an alignment issue, highlighting unprofessional behavior from staff.

While these instances are regrettable, they stand out as exceptions. We remain committed to delivering the high standards our customers expect and deserve.

Good Guys Garage Photos

Good Guys Garage 0
Good Guys Garage 1
Good Guys Garage 2
Good Guys Garage 3
Good Guys Garage 4
Good Guys Garage 5

Good Guys Garage Location

Good Guys Garage Customer Reviews

Do not use this garage, they are not reputable. I took my car there to have new tires installed as we have done in the past. This time they scraped up the inside of my rim getting the tire on or off. (Scrape is inside the bead) We went back for them to see it and they would not accept ownership of the damages nor did they offer to repair the rim.

Oct 31, 2024 · Jessica Lee

My son had tires put on front end on car, first a tech drove his car into shop with the emergency brake on, my son had to stop him and tell him to remove the brake. Before car was taken into shop it had no alignment issues, I verified before leaving . After my sons appt, he came back furious because the steering had become affected, and pulled to the right , a noticeable problem, immediately following the mount and balance. I called shop some flunky named James spoke to me and my son. He was completely unprofessional, took no responsibility for the problem, instigated for my son to come back and fight him. Extremely rude, .. dont go get any work done here. How does a so called man have a business when he acts like child and encourages customers to come back for an altercation. Smh.

Jan 24, 2025 · Mahalia Wright

Quality work, good value, great communication and friendly. Above and beyond that, they are local owned and operated, keeping downtown Newark strong.

Nov 05, 2024 · Christopher O'Reilly

The name holds true: These guys really are "Good Guys!" James and his team clearly explained why I had uneven tire wear and presented me with multiple tire options for my vehicle. The price of repairs was very cost-effective and even less than I expected. They took the time to show me what was causing the issues I was experiencing and provided sound advice on how to properly maintain my vehicle in the future. They really went above and beyond to help me and answered every question I had. They should rename this place "Great Guys Garage" because that is what they are. I highly recommend this place to anyone who is looking for a reputable mechanic and honest advice.

Jan 27, 2021 · Barant Pastorek

Was in a tough spot and needed a tire quickly. Called down to see if they had a set in my size. The gentleman went and looked through the entire stock and found a set and was able to get them switched out with in the hour. Outstanding customer service and very reasonable price. Would definitely recommend.

Nov 28, 2023 · Erik Frahn

Took my car there twice to get work done. Both times have been amazing very professional and honest. No issues with the work or the customer service. Great experience with great guys

May 01, 2025 · jacob nicodemus