Smithwest Service Center Inc.

Smithwest Service Center Inc. ico

(291 reviews)

Auto Repair StationsNew YorkSuffolk CountySaint JamesMiddle Country Road

Suffolk County . New York

Close Now

  • Overview
  • Intro
  • Photos
  • Location
  • Reviews
  • +1 631-265-9885
  • smithwestservice.com
  • 795 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA

Operating Hours

Monday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Sunday Closed

Smithwest Service Center Inc. Introduce

For vehicle owners in St. James, New York, Smithwest Service Center Inc. is an established auto repair station providing a range of automotive services. Located at 795 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA, this center aims to address various vehicle maintenance and repair needs. You can reach them by phone at (631) 265-9885 or +1 631-265-9885.

Environment and Customer Experience

Customer experiences at Smithwest Service Center Inc. appear to be varied, presenting a mixed picture of the environment and service quality. One review highlights a highly positive experience, emphasizing an "excellent experience," "incredibly fast" service, and a "spotless" environment, specifically mentioning a clean bathroom and waiting area. This suggests an effort by the business to maintain a tidy and comfortable space for customers, which can significantly enhance the waiting experience during vehicle service. The staff in this account were described as "super friendly" and made the customer "feel right at home," indicating a welcoming and approachable atmosphere.

However, another review offers a stark contrast, describing the experience as "Awful" and feeling "ripped off." This feedback focuses on perceived overpricing for a New York State vehicle inspection and subsequent brake repair, with the customer finding a "reputable shop close by" that quoted 25% cheaper for the same work, and disagreed on the necessity of immediate brake replacement for inspection. The oil change price was also deemed "excessive" and comparable to "dealership price." This discrepancy in reviews suggests that while some customers may experience excellent service and fair pricing, others might encounter issues related to cost transparency and the necessity of recommended repairs. The environment, in terms of cleanliness and friendliness, might be consistently positive, but the financial aspect of the service can vary significantly from one customer's perspective to another.

Services Offered

As a general "Auto Repair Station," Smithwest Service Center Inc. would typically offer a comprehensive suite of services to maintain and repair various vehicle systems. Based on the customer reviews, key services include:

  • Vehicle Inspections: They perform vehicle inspections, specifically mentioned in the context of passing or failing due to brake conditions. This is a common service required by state regulations (e.g., NYS inspections).
  • Brake Services: Diagnosis, repair, and replacement of brake components (pads, rotors, calipers). The review highlights a situation where brake service was recommended and quoted.
  • Oil Changes: A fundamental routine maintenance service, indicated by the customer mentioning the "oil change price."

Beyond these explicitly mentioned services, a full-service auto repair center generally provides:

  • Routine Maintenance: Such as fluid checks and top-offs, tire rotations, and filter replacements (air filter, cabin filter).
  • Tire Services: Sales, mounting, balancing, and repair of tires.
  • Engine Diagnostics and Repair: Addressing issues indicated by the check engine light, engine performance problems, and minor to major engine repairs.
  • Steering and Suspension Repair: Repairing and replacing components related to a vehicle's handling and ride comfort, such as shocks, struts, and alignments.
  • Heating and Air Conditioning (HVAC) Services: Diagnosis and repair of vehicle climate control systems.
  • Electrical System Repair: Troubleshooting and fixing issues with a vehicle's wiring, lighting, battery, alternator, and starter.
  • Exhaust System Repair: Repairing or replacing mufflers, catalytic converters, and other exhaust components.

The ability to handle New York State inspections suggests they are equipped to assess a vehicle's compliance with state safety and emissions standards, which requires a broad understanding of vehicle systems.

Key Features and Potential Strengths/Weaknesses

Based on the provided information, some key features and perceived strengths/weaknesses of Smithwest Service Center Inc. can be identified:

  • Speed of Service: One review praises "incredibly fast" service, indicating efficiency and potentially quick turnaround times for certain repairs or maintenance tasks. This is a significant advantage for busy customers.
  • Cleanliness and Comfort: The "spotless" condition of the waiting area and bathroom is a notable positive feature, contributing to a more pleasant customer experience. This reflects attention to detail in maintaining the facility.
  • Friendly Staff: The "super friendly" staff is a recurring positive theme, creating a welcoming atmosphere and potentially easing customer anxiety about car repairs.
  • Pricing Concerns: The negative review strongly highlights issues with perceived "crazy" and "excessive" pricing, particularly for inspection-related repairs and oil changes. This suggests a potential lack of competitiveness in pricing compared to other local shops, or at least a perception of it from some customers.
  • Trust and Transparency (Varied Perception): While one customer clearly felt comfortable and well-served, the other felt "ripped off" and questioned the honesty of the inspection recommendation. This indicates that trust and transparency might not be consistently perceived across all customer interactions. A reputable shop aims for consistent honesty and clear communication about necessary repairs and costs.

Promotional Information

No specific promotional offers or discounts are mentioned in the provided customer reviews. Auto repair shops typically use various methods to promote their services:

  • Free Estimates: Offering no-cost assessments for repair work.
  • Online Scheduling: Providing convenience for customers to book appointments online.
  • Service Warranties: Offering a guarantee on parts and labor for a specified period or mileage.
  • Loyalty Programs: Rewarding repeat customers with discounts or exclusive offers.
  • Certifications and Accreditations: Highlighting ASE certifications for technicians, or affiliations with reputable industry organizations.
  • Seasonal Specials: Offering discounts on services like winterization, air conditioning checks, or tire rotations during relevant seasons.

For potential customers in St. James, New York, considering Smithwest Service Center Inc., it would be advisable to inquire about specific service pricing beforehand, especially for inspections and major repairs, and perhaps compare quotes with other local shops to ensure competitive rates, as suggested by the varied customer feedback. While some customers have had excellent experiences with speed and friendliness, the pricing concerns raised by others are a significant factor to consider when choosing an auto repair provider.

Smithwest Service Center Inc. Photos

Smithwest Service Center Inc. 0
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 1
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 2
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 3
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 4
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 5
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 6
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 7
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 8
Smithwest Service Center Inc. 9

Smithwest Service Center Inc. Location

Smithwest Service Center Inc. Customer Reviews

I had an excellent experience at this service shop! The service was incredibly fast, and everything was spotless, including their bathroom and waiting area. The staff were super friendly and made me feel right at home. Highly recommend!

May 03, 2025 · Franca M.

Awful. Ripped off. Failed my car for inspection bc of brakea. Quoted me a crazy price to replace. Went to another reputable shop close by and was told brakes would pass but recommended changing. Quoted a price 25% cheaper for same work so did it. Also oil change price excessive and like a dealership price. Never go again.

May 19, 2025 · Mitch Drucker

Brian helped me with putting on the spare tire. He responded promptly and got me on my way. I then had SmithWest put on a new tire for me. They had the part within a day and were able to get me in. 10/10 customer service. Would highly recommend them to anyone for their car care needs.

Dec 19, 2024 · Patrick Fava

Great service. I was in and out. This place is very clean and organized. I had absolutely no issues. Will definitely go there in the future for whatever I need for my car ! Refreshing to know that there are people out there that still do their job and do it well with no issues! Thank you!

Jan 17, 2025 · Courtney Maniaci

What a lifesaver. Brian M, for the WIN!!! Quick response, awesome customer service and solid work. A+++++. THANK YOU BRIAN M!!!!

Dec 12, 2024 · Amy Demarle Ormond