Penneys Car Care

Auto Repair StationsNew YorkSuffolk CountySaint JamesNew York 25A
Suffolk County . New York
Close Now
- Overview
- Intro
- Photos
- Location
- Reviews
- +1 631-862-9663
- 545 NY-25A, St James, NY 11780, USA
Operating Hours
Penneys Car Care Introduce
Penneys Car Care, located at 545 NY-25A, St James, NY 11780, USA, is an "Auto Repair Station" that has clearly established itself as a reliable and trustworthy automotive service provider within the local community. The information provided, particularly through glowing customer reviews, paints a picture of a business deeply committed to quality workmanship and honest customer interactions. Local users in St. James and the surrounding areas can contact them directly via phone at (631) 862-9663 or mobile at +1 631-862-9663 for their vehicle maintenance and repair needs.
The environment at Penneys Car Care, while not explicitly detailed in terms of physical attributes, can be inferred from the consistently positive customer feedback. The emphasis on "friendly" and "nice" staff suggests a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. In an auto repair shop, this typically translates to a clean and organized reception area, professional service bays, and an overall sense of order that instills confidence in customers. The presence of key individuals like **Steven** and **Kathy**, who are directly involved in customer interactions and service oversight, creates a personalized and approachable environment. This personal touch is often highly valued by customers seeking reliable auto care.
Penneys Car Care offers a comprehensive range of services, catering to both routine maintenance and more significant automotive issues. The reviews highlight their versatility:
- **General Maintenance:** One customer explicitly states they can be "counted on" for a "simple inspection." This indicates that Penneys Car Care handles routine preventative maintenance services such as oil changes, tire rotations, fluid checks, battery testing, and general vehicle inspections, which are crucial for extending a vehicle's lifespan and ensuring its safety.
- **Major Work/Repairs:** The reviews confirm their capability for "any major work." This suggests they are equipped to handle complex mechanical issues, engine diagnostics, brake system repairs, transmission services, electrical system troubleshooting, and suspension work, among other significant repairs. The ability to return a vehicle "running as smooth as 1st day I drove it" after diagnosing an issue further underscores their technical proficiency in resolving complex problems.
- **Diagnostic Services:** The process described by a customer, where Steve "called me back after diagnosing the issue," highlights their systematic approach to identifying vehicle problems before proceeding with repairs. This diagnostic capability is fundamental to effective and efficient auto repair.
The features that truly set Penneys Car Care apart, as articulated by their customers, are rooted in their core values:
- **Exceptional Honesty and Trustworthiness:** This is perhaps their most celebrated feature. Customers repeatedly use terms like "honest guy" and "very trustworthy." In an industry where trust can often be a concern, Penneys Car Care has evidently built a strong reputation for integrity, ensuring customers feel confident that they are receiving accurate assessments and fair recommendations.
- **Reliability and Consistency:** Phrases such as "does a great job and does it right the first time" and "can be counted on" point to consistent, high-quality workmanship. This reliability means customers can bring their vehicles in with confidence, knowing the issue will be effectively addressed without the need for repeat visits for the same problem.
- **Strong Communication:** The fact that Steven "called me back after diagnosing the issue" demonstrates clear and proactive communication. This ensures customers are kept informed about their vehicle's status, the nature of the problem, and the proposed solutions, empowering them to make informed decisions. Kathy is also noted for setting up appointments smoothly, indicating efficient front-office communication.
- **Skilled Leadership:** Steven is lauded as "excellent" and "super nice," indicating that his personal qualities and oversight contribute significantly to the positive shop culture and quality of work. His ability to oversee both routine maintenance and major repairs further solidifies his role as a competent and reliable leader.
- **Customer Satisfaction and Outcomes:** Customers express immense satisfaction with the "outcome" of their repairs, with one car "running as smooth as 1st day I drove it." This focus on delivering tangible, positive results for their clients is a cornerstone of their service.
Regarding promotional information, Penneys Car Care relies heavily on the power of positive word-of-mouth and strong customer testimonials. The provided reviews serve as incredibly compelling promotional material. A recommendation from a "family member" is often the most trusted form of advertising, and the fact that a customer "couldn't have been happier with the outcome" reinforces this.
While specific promotional offers or discounts are not mentioned in the provided information, the consistently high praise for their honesty, reliability, and excellent service acts as their primary marketing strategy. In the auto repair industry, a reputation for integrity and quality workmanship is far more valuable than any fleeting discount. For local users in St. James, Penneys Car Care presents itself as a highly recommended auto repair station where you can expect straightforward communication, effective repairs done correctly the first time, and a trustworthy team led by Steven. Their existing customers are their most effective promoters, ensuring a steady flow of business based on demonstrated excellence.
Penneys Car Care Photos
Penneys Car Care Location
Penneys Car Care Customer Reviews
Steven is excellent. Super nice honest guy who does a great job and does it right the first time. Awesome service and very trustworthy! Whether it’s a simple inspection or any major work he can be counted on
May 03, 2025 · James Kane
I went Penneys on a recommendation from a family member and couldn't have been happier with the outcome. Spoke to Kathy ,set up appointment , Steve called me back after diagnosing the issue. Got my vehicle back running as smooth as 1st day I drove it, Thanks
Apr 12, 2025 · Thomas B
Called the shop at 11:00am on a Saturday asked about an oil change and inspection. I said I might need brakes but not sure. I was told I could just bring it by now if I liked or make an appointment. I brought them the car and I was able to wait while the oil change was done and the inspection. Got advice on the tires and brakes but the car was good to go. I was there less than an hour. What an amazing experience. Very nice people and great mechanics. Thanks Pennys will recommend you to everybody I know.
Dec 21, 2024 · Arthur B
I’ve taken our cars here 3 times without any issues. Not only that, but I completely trust that they are not making up any issues. Whatever they say the problem is, is the truth. Honest mechanic, fair prices.
Apr 16, 2025 · John Juhasz
Devin helped me tremendously when I had tire blow out after hitting a deep pothole.Despite having a full schedule already when I drove in, he ordered and installed tire on same day (rush), after placing my spare so I could complete my 300 mile return home on the next day! Thank you!
Apr 22, 2025 · K Palatianos
More Auto Repair Stations Near Me

St. James BP Automotive Center
525 N Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(23)
Close Now

Dowling Brothers Auto Body Inc
400 Lake Ave, St James, NY 11780, USA
(26)
Close Now

AJu2019s Garage
386 Lake Ave, St James, NY 11780, USA
(5)
Close Now

K D S Automotive Services Inc.
255 Lake Ave, St James, NY 11780, USA
(21)
Close Now

Nettys Auto Shop
10 School St, St James, NY 11780, USA
(5)
Close Now

Genesis of Smithtown Service
587 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
Close Now

Genesis of Smithtown Parts
587 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
Close Now

Perpetual Auto Care
779B Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(2)
Close Now

Litos Customs
789 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(18)
Close Now

Smithwest Service Center Inc.
795 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(291)
Close Now

Empire Volvo Cars Smithtown Service
633 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(116)
Close Now

Competition Subaru of Smithtown Parts
601 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780, USA
(3)
Close Now

Recommended
salvage yards riverside ca
(607)
+1 800-962-22773760 Pyrite St, Riverside, CA 92509, USA
clean energy fuel station
8 Grand Blvd, Brentwood, NY 11717, USA
george's fontana
(242)
+1 909-822-34029684 Sierra Ave., Fontana, CA 92335, USA
smog check in san fernando ca
(48)
+1 661-944-290037855 90th St E #B, Littlerock, CA 93543, USA
autozone auto parts aberdeen car parts
(906)
+1 818-485-052113200 Osborne St, Arleta, CA 91331, USA
empire mazda service & parts
(142)
+1 631-479-3874660 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station, NY 11746, USA
Related Categories
Popular

Essential Tips for Towing Cars Behind RVs Safely and Confidently
Jun 04, 2025
How to Get Emergency Fuel Delivered Quickly: Practical Tips and Reliable Services
Jun 04, 2025
How to Find and Use Towing Service Discounts and Coupons for Reliable Roadside Assistance
Jun 04, 2025
How to Prevent Car Battery Drainage: Practical Tips to Keep Your Vehicle Running Smoothly
Jun 04, 2025
How to Get Your Car Towed Without Damage: Expert Tips and Advice
Jun 04, 2025
What to Do If Your Car’s Brakes Fail on the Road – Essential Safety Steps
Jun 04, 2025
How to Get Help with a Broken Down RV: Essential Tips for Roadside Assistance
Jun 04, 2025