Pine Island Auto Inc.

Pine Island Auto Inc. ico

(40 reviews)

Auto Repair StationsNew YorkOrange CountyPine IslandCounty Route 1

Orange County . New York

Close Now

  • Overview
  • Intro
  • Photos
  • Location
  • Reviews
  • +1 845-981-7102
  • www.pineislandauto.com
  • 642 County Rte 1, Pine Island, NY 10969, USA

Operating Hours

Monday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Sunday Closed

Pine Island Auto Inc. Introduce

Pine Island Auto Inc., located at 642 County Rte 1, Pine Island, NY 10969, USA, operates within the "Auto Repair Stations" category, signifying its role in providing a range of services for vehicle maintenance and repair. With contact phone numbers (845) 981-7102 and mobile +1 845-981-7102, they serve the local community, offering solutions for various automotive needs.

As an "Auto Repair Station," Pine Island Auto Inc.'s primary function is to diagnose, maintain, and repair vehicles. This encompasses a broad spectrum of services, from routine inspections and preventative maintenance to more complex repairs involving engine, transmission, brakes, suspension, and electrical systems. Their role is to ensure the safe and efficient operation of vehicles for their clientele, providing both essential upkeep and solutions to unexpected mechanical issues. The nature of their business requires them to be equipped with diagnostic tools, repair equipment, and a knowledgeable staff capable of addressing diverse automotive problems.

The **environment** at Pine Island Auto Inc., based on the provided customer reviews, presents a dichotomy. One review describes a negative experience, suggesting an environment where critical vehicle issues were overlooked during an inspection, and unnecessary services were pushed. This perspective portrays an environment that might lack thoroughness or transparency, leading to distrust. Conversely, another review paints a very positive picture, describing a "great, professional, friendly place" that is "quick" and "very thorough." This suggests an environment where customer education and detailed explanations are prioritized, fostering a sense of trust and comfort. A truly professional auto repair environment aims for cleanliness, organization, and clear communication channels, ensuring customers feel at ease and confident in the service they receive.

The **services** offered by Pine Island Auto Inc. would typically include a standard range for an "Auto Repair Station." Based on the reviews, these services definitely include:

  • Vehicle Inspections: As noted in both reviews, they conduct vehicle inspections, likely including state-mandated safety and emissions checks.

  • Tire Services: One review specifically mentions a "huge tear in the back left tire" and "alignment issues," implying that tire inspection, repair, and alignment are services they should offer, even if not properly identified in one instance. A comprehensive auto repair shop would typically handle tire sales, mounting, balancing, rotation, and repair.

  • General Maintenance and Repair: The positive review mentions having their car "serviced/repaired," indicating they handle routine maintenance like oil changes, fluid checks, filter replacements, and more complex mechanical repairs for various vehicle systems.

  • Diagnostic Services: To address issues like alignment problems or other unspecified car troubles, they would employ diagnostic tools to pinpoint the root cause of issues.

  • Brake Services: Often a core offering, involving inspection, repair, and replacement of brake components.

  • Engine and Electrical System Repairs: Common services for an auto repair station to address performance issues, check engine lights, and electrical malfunctions.

  • Suspension and Steering Repairs: Ensuring the vehicle handles correctly and provides a smooth ride.

  • Based on the differing reviews, the quality and thoroughness of these services might vary, or customer expectations and experiences could differ significantly.

The **features** of Pine Island Auto Inc. are presented with a degree of contrast in the customer feedback. On one hand, a customer experienced a lack of thoroughness in inspection, an attempt to sell an unnecessary service ($70 wiper blades), and a refusal to refund the inspection fee despite failing the car for issues not initially identified. This points to potential issues with **integrity**, **thoroughness**, and **customer satisfaction management**. This individual labelled them as "con artists," suggesting a negative perception of their business practices.

On the other hand, a highly positive review highlights features such as:

  • Professionalism and Friendliness: Described as a "great, professional, friendly place."

  • Efficiency: Services are provided "quick."

  • Thoroughness and Detailed Explanations: "Very thorough and explained everything to me in great detail," which is a crucial feature for building customer trust and understanding, especially when dealing with complex repairs.

  • Fair Pricing: "Their prices are very fair," indicating good value for the services provided.

  • No Unnecessary Sales: They "don’t try to sell you something you don’t need," which directly contradicts the first review's experience and is a highly valued trait in the auto repair industry.

  • High Recommendation: The reviewer "highly recommend Pine Island Automotive to everyone, Even if you have to travel To get there," signifying strong customer satisfaction and loyalty.

This stark contrast suggests that the business's features might be perceived differently based on individual experiences, or there could be inconsistencies in service delivery across different visits or technicians.

Regarding **promotional information**, no specific promotions are detailed in the provided data. However, typical "Auto Repair Stations" often engage in various marketing and promotional activities to attract and retain customers. These might include:

  • Seasonal Maintenance Specials: Offering discounts on services like winterization, AC checks, or tire rotations during specific times of the year.

  • New Customer Discounts: Providing an introductory offer to first-time clients.

  • Loyalty Programs: Rewarding repeat customers with discounts or exclusive services.

  • Online Scheduling: Offering the convenience of booking appointments through their website.

  • Guarantees on Workmanship: Providing a warranty on parts and labor to instill confidence in their repairs.

  • Transparency in Pricing: While not explicitly a promotion, clearly communicated and fair pricing, as mentioned in one review, can act as a strong draw.

  • Customer Testimonials: Showcasing positive reviews on their website or in their physical location, which, in the case of Pine Island Auto Inc., would likely highlight the positive feedback about thoroughness, fair pricing, and detailed explanations.

  • Given the conflicting reviews, Pine Island Auto Inc. might benefit from proactively addressing customer concerns and showcasing consistent, positive experiences to build a more uniformly positive reputation. Emphasizing their stated features of thoroughness, fair pricing, and clear communication would be crucial in their promotional messaging.

In conclusion, Pine Island Auto Inc. in Pine Island, NY, operates as an "Auto Repair Station" offering essential vehicle maintenance and repair services, including inspections and tire-related work. Customer experiences are notably polarized, with some praising their professionalism, thoroughness, fair pricing, and excellent communication, while others express significant dissatisfaction regarding perceived lack of thoroughness and questionable sales practices. This highlights the importance for potential customers to consider both perspectives and perhaps engage in direct communication or seek initial consultations to gauge if the service aligns with their expectations. Their accessibility via phone and location on County Rte 1 makes them a local option for automotive needs, but the varied feedback suggests a need for careful consideration.

Pine Island Auto Inc. Photos

Pine Island Auto Inc. 0
Pine Island Auto Inc. 1
Pine Island Auto Inc. 2
Pine Island Auto Inc. 3
Pine Island Auto Inc. 4
Pine Island Auto Inc. 5
Pine Island Auto Inc. 6
Pine Island Auto Inc. 7
Pine Island Auto Inc. 8
Pine Island Auto Inc. 9

Pine Island Auto Inc. Location

Pine Island Auto Inc. Customer Reviews

I left my car for an inspection on 4/14 and they never saw the huge tear in the back left tire and said they would pass the inspection as long as I changed out my wiper blades for $70 which were perfectly fine mind you, so after I refused they still charged me $21 before giving my keys back for the inspection and said the car failed. So I took it somewhere else where they identified a huge tear a nail in my tire and alignment issues, I paid to have them fixed right then and there and I was on my way. I will go there from now on as I feel they actually did there job unlike these con artists here at pine island auto

Apr 15, 2025 · Joe Pironti

Finally!!! I found a great, professional, friendly place to have my car serviced/repaired. Not only are they quick, But they were very thorough and explained everything to me in great detail. I highly recommend Pine Island Automotive to everyone, Even if you have to travel To get there. Their prices are very fair, and they don’t try to sell you something you don’t need. Thanks guys good job.👍

May 01, 2025 · Michael Balk

I purchased a work van that I knew was in need of various repairs. I brought the van into Pine Island Auto and was very pleased with the personalized service and attention I received from Kyle. I was particularly impressed by the digital inspection process, which was sent to me in a comprehensive and easy to understand document including pictures to show me the problematic components and a clear explanation of why these services were necessary. I’ve been in business myself for nearly a decade and this was the best experience I’ve had dealing with a repair shop. After this visit to see the guys at Pine Island Auto I’ve made a decision to service my entire fleet of work vans (and even my personal cars) here. Over all, it was the wonderful hospitality, integrity, and obvious pride in doing business the right way that won me over as a lifetime customer. - Steve

Feb 01, 2025 · steven scalici

We love Pine Island Auto! They are very knowledgeable and always have the advice and or knowledge to fix our car issues . We trust them very much . Definitely recommend them .

May 03, 2025 · Stacey Mydosh

Jeff, the owner of Pine Island auto is a true talent and gentleman. Honest and fair in his pricing and works on your vehicle like his own. I feel he is best at diagnosing issues. My latest truck had a few and he pin pointed them and fixed the problems. Truck is back to new plus he undercoated my truck for winter protection of salt leading to undercarriage rust and rot. Super happy with this auto repair company. I would highly recommend.

Nov 05, 2024 · Robert McRae